RAPID CITY, S.D. – A Box Elder man faces a second trial in a fatal stabbing in Rapid City.
A Pennington County judge last month declared a mistrial in a murder case of Barry Allman after discovering that prosecutors failed to inform the defense in a timely manner that immunity had been granted to several key witnesses.
Judge Matt Brown announced a new trial Friday. Allman is accused of stabbing Lance Baumgarten in the chest at a Rapid City apartment in August 2020.
Allman was arrested a day following the stabbing near Wanblee by Oglala Sioux tribal officers.







